“We are still living in an oppressed world…It meant a whole lot for me, to say that people finally realize that some things are okay and some just aren’t.” – Randell Cooper
Randell Cooper spent years fighting for justice after experiencing anti-Black racism at work. On June 24, 2026, almost exactly 7 years after Ms. Cooper was called a “slave” by her supervisor, the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario confirmed that the anti-Black racism was unlawful and awarded Ms. Cooper of remedy of $9,000.
THE RACIST COMMENT
Ms. Cooper worked for Lambretta Pizzeria as a dishwasher. On June 22, 2019, Ms. Cooper’s white supervisor, Kevin Brozyna, told her to “Go back to work, slave.”
Mr. Brozyna’s comment was racist, dehumanizing, and degrading. After the comment, Ms. Cooper felt unsafe and unwelcome at Lambretta because of her race.
To make matters worse, after Ms. Cooper reported the comment, Ms. Cooper felt that her employer did not treat the racist comment seriously. Lambretta Pizzeria was Ms. Cooper’s first job in Canada after moving from The Bahamas, and her first time seeing how Canadian employers address racism.
THE LEGAL BATTLE
In 2019, Ms. Cooper decided to take a stand and filed an HRTO application.
In 2025, HRTO Vice-Chair Mario Silva awarded Ms. Cooper a mere $250, claiming that the anti-Black racism she experienced had no “lasting or significant impact.” Vice-Chair Silva also decided that Lambretta Pizzeria was not legally responsible for their supervisor’s comments.
In response, Ms. Cooper filed a Reconsideration Request. In the Request, Ms. Cooper warned that Vice-Chair Silva’s $250 award sent a message to the public that the HRTO was not taking anti-Black racism seriously, ignoring and exacerbating the impact of anti-Black racism in Canada and the Canadian justice system.
“It wasn’t about the money. [The 2025 decision] showed me it didn’t mean nothing to him and with that being said, Kevin and them did not learn their lesson…it’s like I’m not being heard.” – Ms. Cooper
Ms. Cooper’s first Reconsideration Request was denied. In the Reconsideration Decision, the same Vice-Chair who awarded Ms. Cooper $250, Vice-Chair Silva, refused to use his powers to change the original Decision.
The HRTO’s Reconsideration Decision exposed alarming systemic issues. The Reconsideration Decision appeared to be a copy-pasted ‘boilerplate’ decision, nearly word-for-word identical to at least 16 other decisions Vice-Chair Silva wrote between 2022 and 2025. The Reconsideration Decision did not address Ms. Cooper’s arguments and contained clear errors, i.e., stating that Ms. Cooper’s original Application was denied when it was actually granted.
Ms. Cooper remained determined, filing for a Judicial Review. After learning about Ms. Cooper’s Judicial Review request, the HRTO granted a new hearing to reevaluate the monetary award and reconsider whether Lambretta Pizzeria were legally responsible for Kevin’s racist comment.
A FINAL HEARING
At the HRTO hearing, represented by John No from Parkdale Community Legal Services, Ms. Cooper testified about the dehumanizing impact of Mr. Brozyna’s racist comments and Lambretta Pizzeria’s failure to respond. Ms. Cooper submitted that the $250 Vice-Chair Silva awarded was unreasonably low compared to previous racial discrimination cases, and that Lambretta Pizzeria should be held responsible for their supervisor’s racist behaviour.
The HRTO heard from an expert witness, Dr. Christopher Taylor. Dr. Taylor, a scholar of Black Canadian history and Associate Vice-President of Equity, Diversity, Inclusion and Anti-Racism at the University of Waterloo, spoke about the long history of anti-Black racism and enslavement in Canada.
“One of Canada’s most unknown, and shameful, secrets is its long history of Black enslavement and anti-Black racism. The ‘white-washing’ of Black Canadian history, through the ‘single story’ of the Underground Railroad, has distorted this country’s historical and present-day realities of the oppression that Black people continue to face just to exist as equal members of society.” – Dr. Taylor
Mr. Roger Love from the Ontario Human Rights Commission also made submissions, emphasizing that the use of racist language like the term “slave” perpetuates anti-Black racism.
VICTORY
Vice-Chair Kelly Barker’s Decision, issued on June 24, 2026, demonstrates the power and impact of Ms. Cooper’s efforts.
In the Decision, Vice-Chair Barker states; “the term “slave” being used against a Black employee is racist and egregious.” Vice-Chair Barker confirmed that “an employee who is called an egregious racist name would be degraded and dehumanized and impacted in a serious manner,” and that the term slave was a “historically loaded term, designed to devalue and delegitimize” Black people.
Mr. No believes that the $9,000 award Ms. Cooper won may be one of the highest amounts that the HRTO has awarded for a single racist comment. Vice-Chair Barker’s finding of the corporation’s liability was also a helpful affirmation of the jurisprudence, states Mr. No.
“This decision acknowledges what I call ‘diachronic realities’ – that the past continues to shape the present, and the future. Moreover, it is the legal system admitting that Black people, particularly Black women, live in the afterlife of enslavement. While enslavement legally ended in 1834 in Canada, hundreds of years of ideological oppression shapes the world we live in.” – Dr. Taylor
Ms. Cooper fought back in the face of a legal system built on racism and colonialism. Anti-Black racism is deeply engrained in Canadian society and the Canadian legal system, continuing to the present day.
This is an important victory for Ms. Cooper and others seeking justice in the future. In reflecting on the Decision, Ms. Cooper sent solidarity to others who are considering taking action in the face of racism and oppression:
“The process was rough. It was a long 6 to 7 years, but the law, they need to open their eyes on some things. Don’t hesitate…It might be rough right now, you don’t know if you will win or lose, just keep going. See it through.” – Ms. Cooper
